Senators Propose Sweeping Changes to the Taxation of Estates and Inherited Gains
Vermont senator Bernie Sanders (D) has introduced legislation that would require more estates to pay estate tax and that raises the amounts they would pay. Another proposed law would eliminate the step-up in basis that inherited assets currently enjoy.
These changes are unprecedented and will radically change current law and significantly reduce inheritances across all tax brackets, particularly for family businesses and family farms. Although legislators have advertised this as a tax aimed only at the ultra rich, the reality is it is a just another type of estate tax on individuals with relatively modest means.
Under Sanders’ For the 99.5 Percent Act, the estate tax exemption would be reduced from $11.7 million for individuals and $23.4 million for couples to $3.5 million for individuals and $7 million for couples. Any estate that is valued at under the exemption amount will not pay any federal estate taxes, while those exceeding the exemption threshold would be subject to a progressively increasing tax rate. Estates for individuals valued between $3.5 million and $10 million would be taxed at 45 percent, estates valued between $10 million and $50 million at 50 percent, estates valued at $50 million to $1 billion at 55 percent, and estates over $1 billion at 65 percent. This would be a significant increase from the current tax rate of 40 percent for all estates over the exemption.
The Act would also slash the lifetime gift tax exemption from $11.7 million to $1 million, although individuals would still be able to give away $15,000 a year without the gift counting toward the lifetime limit.
A group of senators, including Sen. Sanders, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), and Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), has also introduced the Sensible Tax and Equity Promotion (STEP) Act that would eliminate the step-up in basis that beneficiaries receive when they inherit property. Currently, if someone inherits property, that property’s cost basis is “stepped up” in value to the property’s current value. This means that if the property is sold right away, no capital gains are due on the sale. If instead the property is held onto for a few years before it is sold and it rises in value, capital gains will be owed on the difference between the sale value and the stepped-up basis.
The STEP Act changes all this. The proposal would require an estate to pay tax on all previously untaxed gains. This means that if an estate includes property that has increased in value, the estate would have to pay taxes on that increase. However, the Act would allow the first $1 million of appreciated assets to pass without taxation. In addition, families that inherit a farm or business would be able to pay the tax in installments over a 15-year period. Any taxes paid under the bill would be deductible from the estate tax.
For example, currently, if a business was purchased for $300,000 but was worth $1 million at the time of the owner’s death, and the heirs sold it, they would be taxed based on anything over $1 million on the sale. However, Biden’s proposal would mean that the business owner’s heirs would be taxed on the $700,000 gain from the original $300,000 purchase price. By taxing the unrealized gain at death, heirs would be hit at the transfer, regardless of whether they sell the asset. Consequently, heirs would have to pay as much as 40% tax, which would require selling just to cover the taxes, and they would also have to pay income taxes on any gains realized over the original purchase price, or basis of the business.
It is unclear whether either proposed law has the support to pass the full Senate in their current forms. It is unlikely that any Republicans will support the legislation, so the Democrats would have to pass the bills through reconciliation, which would require all 50 Democratic senators to agree.